Montesquieu's Greatest Mark on Philosophy Essay

Montesquieu's Greatest Mark on Philosophy Essay

Length: 1525 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Doubtless, if Montesquieu were forced to choose a favorite mathematical formula, he would pick the average function. For even among the great thinkers of the French Enlightenment, the baron de Montesquieu stands out as an especially impassioned advocate for moderation. Montesquieu, of course, left his greatest mark on the philosophy of the governance through his great work The Spirit of the Laws. Though certainly his earlier work The Persian Letters sowed the seeds of many of the ideas featured in his chef d’œuvre. In particular, Montesquieu spends some time in both works examining the universe of possible governments. But he advocates not, in fact, for republicanism or, perhaps less surprisingly, despotism. Rather, Montesquieu supports the “moderate” position: a government less despotic than despotism, and yet less democratic than democracy or republicanism. He makes the case, in other words, for rule by an enlightened monarch.
Montesquieu himself divides the principal forms of government into three broad groupings in his seminal work The Spirit of the Laws. At one extreme he places the “republican” government, at the other the despotic. The “monarchical” he places somewhere in the center (Spirit of the Laws bk. II, ch. 1). The ordering alone belies Montesquieu’s stance; of course other evidence is more explicit.
To begin, Montesquieu does little to disguise his distaste for despotic governments. Even Usbek, Rhedi and Rica, Montesquieu’s invented Persian aristocrats in The Persian Letters—whose nobility flows from a despotic Asian government—find fault with the despotic system, as if to underline the system’s lack of merit. Usbek says of European states, “A week’s imprisonment, or a small fine, impress the mind of a...

... middle of paper ...

Government in moderation is Montesquieu’s prescription for political success. He finds obvious and glaring faults with the despotic system, from the cruelty despots show their subjects to the instability of the despotic government as an institution. The republican system, as Montesquieu sees it, is not without its merits. But he seems certain that such a system is doomed to succumb to human caprice. Monarchy, though, strikes a balance in Montesquieu’s eyes. It neither rests upon the resolve of the citizenry, nor allows a prince the kind of unchecked control that subjects a population to the whims of a single man.

Works Cited
Montesquieu, Charles-Louis de Secondat, baron de La Brède. The Persian Letters. Trans. C. J. Betts. London: The Penguin Group, 1973.
—. The Spirit of the Laws. Ed. J.V. Prichard. Trans. Thomas Nugent. London: Bell & Sons, Ltd., 1914.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Persian Letters by Montesquieu

-      The book The Persian Letters by Montesquieu is a fictional novel that was written by the author so he could comment on the society in which he was living. This novel has served as a good example of the ideas that were present during the early Enlightenment. There are many ideas and themes that Montesquieu discusses by using the point of view of two Persian travelers in Europe that correspond with letters to each other and others back in Persia. By using a foreigner's perspective, Montesquieu was able to present things in a way that gave a much more lasting effect then if he had used two Frenchman commenting on their own country....   [tags: Persian Letters Montesquieu]

Free Essays
974 words (2.8 pages)

The Philosophy Of The World 's Greatest Evils Essay

- ... Contrary to classical beliefs about reason however, Scottish philosopher David Hume finds that rationality is simply mathematical and logical reasoning, not necessarily entirely free from the passions and emotions as Plato suggests. Furthermore, his views in relation to reason and religion are stated in his ‘Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding’, that“ There is not a greater number of philosophical reasoning’s, displayed upon any subject, than those, which prove the existence of a Deity, and refute the fallacies of Atheists; and yet the most religious philosophers still dispute whether any man can be so blinded as to be a speculative atheist.” (149) Until the end of the 18th century,...   [tags: Faith, Religion, God, Philosophy of religion]

Powerful Essays
1673 words (4.8 pages)

Mark Twain : The Greatest Writers Of The 19th Century Essay

- ... This newspaper was called “The Hannibal Western Union.” Then, when he was 21 years old he began to take up the art of piloting steamboats. In 1859 he was a licensed steam boat pilot. Once this happened, it was very simple for him to find jobs navigating the wide Mississippi. In 1861, his steamboat career came to a screeching halt because the Civil War had started. Once the civil war had started, nobody was traveling the river. So Clemens thought, what better to do than join the Confederate Army....   [tags: Mark Twain, Adventures of Huckleberry Finn]

Powerful Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Teaching Philosopy: How to Mark a Book by Mortimer Adler Essays

- For a student to be successful in college English, they need to understand there is an intimate relationship between reading and writing. One skill reinforces the other. Competent readers make competent writers. The challenge is universal: How do we transition students from high school to college English. I would like to say I have the answer, but the answer changes with each class and every semester. There isn’t one set model, and I understand that my model will constantly evolve and reflect my student’s needs....   [tags: active reader, writing]

Powerful Essays
841 words (2.4 pages)

Philosophy Q&A Essay

- Question: Assess the influence of classical liberal political philosophy upon the structure and function of the present day Canadian Government. Thesis: Classical Liberalism, started by John Locke, and continued by philosophers such as Jean-Jacque Rousseau, Montesquieu, Jeremy Bentham, and John Stuart Mill were passed through Britain’s Government into the Canadian Government, who has been influenced by all of the philosophers mentioned. Argument/Analysis: POV#1: John Locke’s preference of Monarchies influenced the Canadian Governments structure....   [tags: Philosophy]

Powerful Essays
865 words (2.5 pages)

Writing in Philosophy Essays

- Edie Brickell and the New Bohemians once sang that "philosophy is a walk on the slippery rocks." While philosophy may be a tricky subject to grasp, full of seemingly unanswerable questions and paradoxes, writing in philosophy is pretty much the same as any other academic writing done in college. Philosophy papers still revolve around a thesis, still rely on evidence and logic to prove their theses, and are still written to show students' understandings or to gain new understandings just like any other academic paper....   [tags: Philosophy]

Powerful Essays
1349 words (3.9 pages)

History of Philosophy Essay

- Until now, I have simply accepted education as it has been presented me, blind to fact that there was any kind of well developed philosophy behind it. After being introduced to the main educational philosophies, perennialism, essentialism, progressivism and social resconstructionism, I have had the opportunity to decide for myself which ones I believe in and why. I must agree with Thomas Locke that we are born into this world a blank slate. Living in such an affluent society, education in America is provided and required of all citizens....   [tags: philosophy]

Powerful Essays
1224 words (3.5 pages)

Philosophy of Ethics Essay

- The word “ethics” comes from Greek ethikas meaning character. Today, we use ethics to describe the normative standard of behavior. The history of philosophical ethics has been broken up into five rational methods: Virtue, Traditional, Modern, and Post-Modern Ethics. Within these periods, the philosophy of ethics changed along with the changes being made within society. The first rational method is Virtue Ethics. The major philosophers during this period were materialists such as Plato, Aristotle, Epicurus, and Plutarch....   [tags: Philosophy ]

Powerful Essays
2229 words (6.4 pages)

Philosophy 101 Essay example

- Philosophy is defined by Webster as "Love and pursuit of wisdom by intellectual means and moral self-discipline" or "Investigation of the nature, causes, or principles of reality, knowledge, or values, based on logical reasoning rather than empirical methods." This essay is a general look at those who pursued that intellectual means, those who investigated, even those who reasoned Reason. Because volumes could be written and this is a rather quick, unworthy paper: apologizes. Hegel's philosophy of History, on of the greatest in the philosophy cannon, is the great philosophers greatest body of work....   [tags: Philosophy]

Powerful Essays
827 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Philiosophy

- Philiosophy Philosophy is an all-important aspect of our lives. It is philosophy that we turn to when have the need to seek out a guiding principle for our lives. Therefore, philosophy holds a prominent place in society and in the world. Basically, everyone is a philosopher, but it takes the creative genius and reasoning of brilliant thinkers to bring about world-shattering concepts. Nevertheless, the common man also ruminates about his life and his unique existence to try to find the meaning of his life....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
506 words (1.4 pages)