Critique on Against Gay Marriage
Is marriage strictly between male and female, or should it also be open for homosexuals? William Bennett, a well known politician believes in the traditional marriage, being between a male and female. His thesis reads “We are engaged in a debate which, in a less confused time, would be considered pointless and even oxymoronic: the question of the same-sex marriage” (409). Not only is this statement bias, but other elements of his work held problems. The way his case was defended was ineffective to his case. The debate held good statements; it just failed to support the statements. His writing also holds other unacceptable elements, giving his work more reasons to be ineffective. William Bennett’s debate “Against Gay Marriage” is ineffective because of its lack of transitions, inability to understand the other side, and the lack of support for his arguments
This article has various different arguments on the subject of same-sex marriage, all leading to why Bennett is against same-sex marriages. To combat against same-sex marriages it must not be allowed anywhere in the United States, described in the article. Bennett argues that allowing gay marriage would result in long-term social damage in the United States. He explains that same-sex marriages will bring negative change to the structure of marriage, saying marriage is already fragile enough and that same-sex marriages would push it off the edge. Additionally Bennett states that Andrew Sullivan, an expert over same-sex marriages, admitted that a homosexual marriage will involve a greater understanding of the need of “extramarital elements.” Bennett then explains that a marriage of a man and a woman doesn’t have “extramarital elements” occur a...
... middle of paper ...
...n traditional marriages but they don’t illegalize marriage altogether. Just because some commit to this doesn’t mean all will. Also Sullivan is described as very intelligent of the matter of same-sex marriages; he still isn’t the representative of the whole gay community. Just because he says that homosexuals are more acceptable to extramarital outlets doesn’t mean it’s true.
William’s article “Against Gay Marriage” was ineffective in saying same-sex marriages aren’t acceptable. The article didn’t flow from statement to statement, adding to the ineffectiveness of his article. Also his lack of understanding the opponent gave reason why William was ineffective. The main reason why this article was ineffective is because of his failure to back his statements up with facts. Until William provides support for his statements, “Against Gay Marriage” will remain ineffective.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Thomas B. Stoddard’s “Gay Marriages: Make Them Legal” is a successfully written argument with some minor flaws in technique. Stoddard uses this article to present his major claim, or central thesis, on the reasons gay marriage should be legalized. He presents his argument using minor claims. In a lecture on February 2, 2005, James McFadden stated a minor claim is the secondary claim in an argument. Stoddard uses minor claims in his discussion of homosexual people being denied their rights by the government and by others who discriminate against them.... [tags: Gay Marriage Essays]
1110 words (3.2 pages)
- Background All decisions we make are guided by an influenced belief or a maxim. A maxim is an individual rule that we use in our negotiations to steer our conduct. Maxims contain our principles and intentions; they point toward our general character. A solid and well intentioned maxim is universalizable. The precise significance of universalizability is contentious, but the most widespread interpretation is that the categorical imperative asks whether the maxim of your action could become one that everyone could act upon in similar circumstances.... [tags: Homosexuality ]
853 words (2.4 pages)
- Ever since the Supreme Court ruled in favor of a “constitutional right” to Same-Sex Marriage, religious opponents of gay marriage placed the decision as “profoundly immortal and unjust” (nytimes.com). Using the idea of religious along with Saunders’ sense of satire, he indicated religious beliefs toward Same-Sex-Marriage that “He did not want men marrying men, or women marrying women, but also what He did not want, in my view, was feminine men marrying masculine women” (Saunders, 67). Bringing in the use of religions in Saunders’ responses, we can see that he is intentionally mocking the majority of religious followers who opposed to gay marriage at the time when this issue rise among the so... [tags: Homosexuality, Gender, Sexual orientation]
1204 words (3.4 pages)
- The Best Argument against Gay marriage: Glen Lavy’s “Gay marriage and the ‘slippery slope’ ” Proponents to the legalization of same sex marriage came up with a lot of reasons as why gay marriage should be legal. The major ones are that not allowing same sex people to get married prevents them from getting legal benefits like hospital visitation, health insurance, family leave and more. They also argued that they are fighting for their rights the same way African Americans were fighting back in the day, and that gay marriage will not threaten our society.... [tags: Gay Marriage and the Slippery Slope, ]
880 words (2.5 pages)
- Rights Versus Wrong In the article, “Against Gay Marriage,” author William Bennett asserts that permitting same-sex marriages would result in extensive social damage. He states that marriage serves as the cornerstone of societal structure. He envisions that societal indifference on marriages will leave future generations in a state of identity confusion. Representing a different perspective, the article “American Marriage in Transition,” composed by Andrew J. Cherlin suggests that as the practical necessity of marriage diminishes, its symbolic importance may be increasing.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality, Marriage]
1084 words (3.1 pages)
- Gallagher’s argument against gay marriage rests on the fact that children are best helped by being raised by both of their biological parents who are within a low conflict marriage. Gallagher then asserts that since children are best off with their biological parents society should limit marriage to a man and a woman in order to protect children. John Corvino identifies that there are missing steps in Gallagher’s arguments against same sex marriage due to the fact that many marriages are currently sanctioned where children are not found to be living with their biological parents.... [tags: Homosexuality, Marriage, Same-sex marriage]
1572 words (4.5 pages)
- America has always been in constant fighting between their different political parties. Everyone holds themselves to different ideals and standards which often conflict when it comes to achieving equilibrium. One of the issues that has come to the forefront is tied to gay marriage. The union of a homosexual couple in the past was frowned upon, recently it has been given more leeway and freedom. Yet, the two sides continue to take their frustrations out on one another. No matter which side you may agree with, understanding the issues that come from supporting either stance is the most important part to finding out your own opinion.... [tags: Same-sex marriage, Homosexuality, Marriage]
1605 words (4.6 pages)
- ... By this he means that society condemns sexuality that does not aid in assisting what natural law theorists find most important, reproduction. However, he disputes that non-reproductive homosexual relationships are immoral and unnatural, because the Catholic Church allows sex with sterile, pregnant and menopausal people. Each of these factors are not condemned as immoral by society even if they are indeed misusing the natural function of the organs. Corvino connects this argument about inconsistency’s to describe how homosexuality does not harm the self or others.... [tags: gay sex, morality, natural]
849 words (2.4 pages)
- Defense of Marriage Act Introduction Within our society and the western hemisphere, it is believed that only a man and a woman should be allowed to participate in the sacred ritual of marriage. These beliefs are instilled through the socialization of society and family. Our society illustrates marriage through the media. Our family illustrates marriage by first hand experience. In a traditional family, we perceive a man and a woman as our parents. Traditionally, people marry with the expectation that reproduction will occur, and one will grow old along side of children, and grandchildren.... [tags: science]
1948 words (5.6 pages)
- Gay parenting and marriage has become publicly accepted by some and rejected by others. Many have come to believe this topic to be immoral and impossible. Society has also realized that the average family has developed into many different forms in the last few years. Gay families have developed and are perceived today that raising kids without both a Mom and Dad, deprives the child from being introduced to both worlds. The approach to this debated topic will be to analyze and to defend the “cons” of gay parenting and marriage.... [tags: Against Gay Marriage, Argumentative Essay]
1804 words (5.2 pages)